I have been wanting to switch email providers for a while. I’ve been using Gmail for almost 2 decades, forwarding email from my other domains. As time has gone on, though, my methods for forwarding email (through my shared web host’s cpanel) have been less dependable/timely, and I have found myself giving out my gmail address more and more. I’ve also completely lost control of my email inbox, with filters I set long ago hiding emails from friends, real emails being eaten by overzealous spam filters, and so many emails coming in I found it hard to keep on top of.
So, I decided a change was in order.
For the provider, I tried out several options.
Proton email was the obvious choice, as they are well reviewed and combine email, storage, documents, and VPN. This all sounded great. EXCEPT: they only let you port 3 domains. Even for the duo account. My partner and I at the least have a personal and professional domain each, and I have two others I would really like to receive email at. Plus they are advertising some AI crud I just don’t want so I decided against Proton.
I also tried Fastmail, paying for it for a month to try out all the features. I like the interface a lot, setting up my custom domains was easy. I was pretty close to going with Fastmail, if I couldn’t get my final choice to work. Fastmail has the option to set up temporary email addresses for signing up for things too, though I use a “catch all” email for this.
I looked at Tuta mail, but didn’t want to be stuck using their email client (I know it is secure by default, but I really want a choice in tools).
I ended up going with mailbox.org. I like the delightfully old school name, the fact that it’s the most affordable option, lets you encrypt your own email with PGP if you want (I have not yet), and it gives you WebDAV and CalDAV as well (which I am also using for todo’s). It is not the easiest option to set up though, and their docs could use some work. Some of the documentation references older menu options, and it’s not super clear exactly what to put in which fields (as opposed to Fastmail, which gave precise directions for different host options). I was also confused about how filters worked – I thought at first I could sync filters across Thunderbird mobile and desktop, but it turns out that Thunderbird mobile doesn’t have filters at all. I did finally find the mailbox.org filters though, under the main settings, and those are plenty to keep the email organized (with the disadvantage that I can’t easily add filters on mobile due to lack of mobile interface).
I have described mailbox.org as “a bunch of open source stuff duct taped together” and that’s still what it feels like.
If I was recommending a solution for someone less technical than I am, I would probably go with Fastmail. But mailbox.org is worth a try, they do have a free trial (as does Fastmail) and both let you set up external domains to see how it works.
A final note: most of my domains I point to a shared host (Reclaim Hosting) with nameservers, and then set the email settings on the web server so I can both host email and my sites. One domain I set up directly on namecheap since I was only using it for email and that was quite a bit fussier. Fastmail has an extra option mailbox.or does not: if you are only using the domain for email, you can set the nameservers to point at fastmail, which is far easier than setting all the options manually.
What’s next?
I still need to change over all the subscriptions and personal contacts I set to gmail.com, and download my gmail archive for safekeeping. Though it’s so impossibly full of spam at this point I probably won’t go through it much.