Getting used to impermanence

In 2022, I gave up on Twitter. I joined Twitter in 2008, along with a bunch of other library types, and the early years were great. When Twitter was down (often) in the early years as it grew, we swarmed to other services like “Plurk” and then swarmed back when Twitter was back up. One of the other places we swarmed was Friendfeed, which I still really miss. It had a wonderful mix of content, thanks to relying on plain ol’ RSS. Google Reader was also a great place to dig deep into discussing content, but it was shut down in 2013.

the very first pokemon I caught, in front of an open laptop with twitter in the background
Pokemon Go Screenshot from the first day of release, with an open laptop with Twitter open in the background.

Last month, I gave up on Pokemon Go, which I had played since the day it came out in 2016. I read the news of its release (on Twitter, of course) and rushed to install the app and catch my first Pokemon from my basement.  You can even see Twitter in the background of my first Pokemon screenshot! As the years went on, Pokemon Go added more social features, and I met many of my neighbors while out playing: participating in raids, on community days, or just wandering around a park. I reached level 43, and while that wasn’t super high it represented a lot of effort on my part, and 8+ years of consistent play.

In November of 2022, Elon Musk acquired Twitter. In March of 2025, a Saudi affiliated company acquired Niantic, the maker of Pokemon Go. Both Musk and the Saudi government have said publicly that they are against lots of things that apply to me and my friends (like not being cis). For both of these things I felt I couldn’t morally use the product anymore, both because I don’t want my activity to contribute to the bottom line for groups or people that act to remove rights from people like me, and because I don’t want to become an unwitting recipient of messages they want to send.

I know all the arguments here: Pokemon Go will continue to be operated as it was! The Saudi government is far removed! Twitter is still where everyone is, you’re just letting all the bad people have the loudest say! And maybe all of that is true, but in my heart I just can’t support it.

So, I deleted Twitter, and I deleted Pokemon Go. These losses hurt worse than Google Reader or Friendfeed, because it felt more like I personally was being cast out of a party everyone else is still at. I’m trying to be more careful going forward, using services only as much as I need to, not putting all my effort into something I can’t control. It’s why I’m so all in on Mastodon – I run my own server, and have an account on a friend’s server, but even if those go away I can migrate my connections somewhere else and not have to build up the entire community again. It’s why I can’t get into Bluesky, I just don’t want to build a bunch of connections and then be forced to give it up because my morals won’t let me use it anymore.

I still miss Pokemon Go. But I’m also OK with letting it go.